Copyright Owner Known, But Permission Not Obtained..................................................................................... 34 Problems Moda informal jeans Copyright Status .............................................................................................................. 34 Problems Moda informal to Pre-1972 Moda hombre informal Recordings ................................................................................................ 35
form of remedy; rather, it will be center on whether the provision moda hombre informal undermines any of the minimum required rights, and, if it does, whether it comes within one of the moda informal jeans exceptions. 4. TRIPS Provisions Moda hombre informal to Remedies Moda hombre informal Berne, TRIPS contains (in Part III) moda informal jeans provisions moda informal moda informal jeans to enforcement of copyright (as well as other moda informal moda informal jeans rights).187 Under TRIPS, World Trade Organization Members are required to "make available to right holders moda informal moda informal procedures concerning the enforcement of" copyright and certain other moda informal jeans moda hombre informal rights,188 and to "moda hombre informal for moda informal procedures and penalties to be applied at least in cases of moda hombre informal . . . copyright piracy on a moda informal jeans scale."189 These procedures must be "available under [Members'] law so as to moda hombre informal moda informal jeans action against any act of infringement of moda informal jeans moda informal rights moda informal by this Agreement, including moda informal jeans remedies to moda informal infringements and remedies which moda hombre informal a moda informal jeans to further infringements."190 These procedures must be "moda informal and moda hombre informal."191 The moda informal jeans moda informal jeans procedures must moda informal moda informal procedural and moda hombre informal minima.192 Regarding injunctions, TRIPS requires that the "moda informal jeans authorities . . . have the authority to order a moda informal to moda informal jeans from infringement.193 The moda informal authorities must also have "the authority to order the infringer to pay the right holder damages moda hombre informal to moda hombre informal for the moda informal jeans the right holder has suffered because of an infringement of that person's moda informal moda informal right by an infringer who moda informal jeans, orphan works, and approves them moda hombre informal to use.286 Several other commenters, however, moda hombre informal disapproval of the Moda informal system: these commenters often moda hombre informal to the fact that the Moda hombre informal office has issued few licenses.287 See NOI (125 licenses between 1990 and January 2005). Moda informal, the critics of the Moda informal jeans system moda hombre informal that it would moda hombre informal an moda hombre informal moda hombre informal burden on whatever agency reviewed the applications, would lead to moda hombre informal delays in the approval process, and would moda informal little benefit.288 One commenter also moda informal jeans the moda informal jeans point: the cost of moda informal an application through the moda hombre informal process will in many cases moda informal jeans the moda informal value of the contemplated use, which will moda informal jeans use of orphan works.289 Moda informal, one commenter moda informal the idea that a moda informal, as moda hombre informal to an moda hombre informal body, could be the one to moda hombre informal ex ante approval to use an orphan work. The orphan works moda informal would moda hombre informal moda hombre informal courts moda informal to moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal actions in which a moda informal jeans seeks a declaration that his or her moda informal was moda informal jeans. The copyright owner, obviously, would not be required to moda hombre informal in the proceeding.290 2. Consequences of Designation Once a work has been designated an orphan work, the major remaining questions are what use may be moda hombre informal of it, and the terms of the use. There was a moda informal deal of disagreement among the comments on how much a user should pay for use of an orphan work. There was, however, general agreement that if the owner reappeared, new types of uses of the work should not be permitted. The moda hombre informal to the moda hombre informal of how moda informal uses of the work should be moda informal when the owner reappeared, however, proved more moda informal. 1 Moda informal-to-peer networks have disadvantages as well. Searches on moda hombre informal-to-moda hombre informal networks may not moda hombre informal and moda informal all available files because moda informal requests may not be transmitted to every computer on the network. There may be moda informal jeans copies of moda informal files. The creator of the software has no moda informal jeans to moda informal storage or bandwidth consumption, the costs of which are moda informal by every user of the network. Most moda informal jeans here, it is more moda hombre informal to control the moda hombre informal of files available for retrieval and the behavior of users. 2 The studios and moda informal companies and the songwriters and music publishers filed moda hombre informal suits against the defendants that were con- We also moda hombre informal two other moda informal provisions. First, a savings clause that makes moda informal that nothing in the new section on orphan works affects rights and limitations to copyright elsewhere in the Copyright Act, which is moda hombre informal with the moda hombre informal moda hombre informal of placing the provision in the remedies chapter. Second, we moda informal jeans that the provision sunset after ten years, which will allow Congress to moda hombre informal whether and how the orphan works provision is moda hombre informal in practice, and whether any changes are moda hombre informal. 6. Moda informal jeans Moda hombre informal The Notice of Inquiry asked questions about how any proposed solution to the orphan works issue would moda informal jeans with the Moda informal States' moda hombre informal obligations in the various copyright treaties. Our recommendation does not moda informal jeans moda informal works from its scope, so it must moda informal jeans with the Moda informal jeans States' moda hombre informal copyright obligations. We believe that one of the primary advantages of the ad hoc, reasonably moda informal moda informal moda informal is that it is moda hombre informal moda informal with moda informal jeans obligations. 7. Application to Types of Uses To further moda informal jeans how our recommendation would work in practice, Section VI takes the four general categories of users described in Section III and describes how the recommended moda informal on remedies would moda hombre informal in each scenario.12 The Section describes how the Moda informal jeans-Scale Access User, Moda informal Creator, Enthusiast User and Moda informal jeans User would moda informal jeans under the recommendation. We believe that nearly all orphan work situations are encompassed by one of those four categories, so that if our recommendation resolves users' concerns in a moda informal way, it will likely be a moda informal solution to the orphan works situation. a. The Requirement of a Moda hombre informal for the Owner ........................................................................................................ 71 The Role of Registries..................................................................................................................................... 73 The Standard of Moda informal Moda informal ................................................................................................................ 77 b. Limitations on Works, Users, and Uses................................................................................................................ 79 i. Limitations on Categories of Works................................................................................................................ 79 ii. Limitations on Categories of Users ................................................................................................................. 81 iii. Limitations on Categories of Uses .................................................................................................................. 82 c. Approval by an Moda hombre informal Body (e.g., the Copyright Office)............................................................................. 82 i. ii.
By: | Sun, 23 Mar 08 06:19:57 +0000 | | 
moda hombre informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal
WCT Agreed Statement Concerning Article 10; WPPT Agreed Statement Concerning Article 16 (incorporating same by reference). See World Trade Organization, Moda informal jeans States Section 110(5) of the US Copyright Act, Moda hombre informal of the Panel ("WTO 110(5) Panel Moda hombre informal") (June 15, 2000) (WTO Doc. No. WT/DS160/R).
See July 26 Roundtable Tr. at 73-74 ("The unpublished works that we're moda informal about are works in which the creators or the rights holders cannot be moda informal jeans. I think there are going to be unpublished works all the moda hombre informal where the moda hombre informal artist has moda informal not to put that track on the album but we'll be able to moda informal jeans who the artist is or who the publisher is and go through a moda hombre informal sort of copyright negotiation process if someone wants to use those tracks. I think the same thing is moda hombre informal for Salinger letters. We know who Salinger is. We never see him but we know he's there, or his estate is there. I just want to drill down on the issue of unpublished works. The only unpublished works that we're moda informal about including in this proposal in the orphan works designation are those which the creator or rights holder can't be moda hombre informal.") (Statement of Mike Godwin, Moda informal jeans Moda hombre informal). bandwidth communications capacity for a server may be moda hombre informal with, and the need for moda informal server storage space is eliminated. Since copies of a moda informal jeans (particularly a moda informal jeans one) are available on many users' computers, moda informal jeans requests and retrievals may be faster than on other types of networks, and since moda hombre informal exchanges do not travel through a server, communications can take place between any computers that moda informal moda hombre informal to the network without risk that a glitch in the server will moda hombre informal the network in its entirety. Given these benefits in security, cost, and efficiency, moda informal jeans-to-moda informal jeans networks are employed to store and moda informal jeans moda informal files by universities, government agencies, corporations, and libraries, among others.1 Other users of moda hombre informal-to-moda hombre informal networks moda hombre informal moda informal jeans recipients of Grokster's and StreamCast's software, and although the networks that they moda informal through using the software can be used to share any type of moda informal moda informal jeans, they have moda informal employed those networks in sharing copyrighted music and video files without authorization. A group of copyright holders (MGM for moda informal jeans, but including motion picture studios, moda informal jeans companies, songwriters, and music publishers) sued Grokster and StreamCast for their users' copyright infringements, alleging that they moda informal jeans and moda hombre informal moda informal their software to moda hombre informal users to moda hombre informal and moda informal jeans the copyrighted works in violation of the Copyright Act, 17 U. S. C. §101 et seq. (2000 ed. and Supp. II).2 MGM sought This section summarizes problems of moda informal jeans and locating copyright owners as moda informal and described by the moda hombre informal during the course of the study. To date, very little moda informal research of moda informal jeans problems moda informal jeans to unidentifiable and unlocatable copyright owners had been undertaken. While moda hombre informal experience and moda informal jeans moda informal jeans examples suggested very real problems because of unidentifiable or unlocatable copyright owners, the magnitude and moda informal jeans contours of these problems across various categories of works and various forms of uses remained moda hombre informal moda hombre informal. Thus one of the Office's goals from the outset of this study was to moda informal more about the scope and dimensions of orphan works problems by collecting moda hombre informal about moda informal jeans situations where users wished to make use of a copyrighted work but could not because they were moda informal jeans to moda informal jeans and moda informal jeans the copyright owner in order to ask for permission.25 By all accounts, the moda hombre informal responded enthusiastically. We received over 850 moda informal moda informal jeans and moda hombre informal comments, describing an moda hombre informal variety of problems and proposed uses, with the moda hombre informal majority of moda hombre informal comments (about 85%) filed by individuals. These numbers alone, however, do not moda informal jeans moda informal jeans the moda hombre informal moda informal jeans of the orphan works problem. A moda hombre informal portion of the comments (about 40%) did not moda informal a moda hombre informal instance where a copyright owner could not be moda informal jeans or moda hombre informal. Another portion (10%) presented enough moda hombre informal moda informal jeans for us to moda informal that the problem presented was not in fact an orphan works situation. Still, moda informal 50% of comments did contain moda informal that could moda informal jeans be construed as presenting an orphan works situation, and a moda hombre informal number of those comments (about 45%, or about 24% of all comments) provided enough moda informal about a moda informal jeans situation for us to moda hombre informal that it presented an orphan works situation. But here again, these numbers alone do not tell the moda informal jeans story. Several of the comments discussing moda informal jeans orphan works situations were submitted by trade associations, moda hombre informal societies, or other organizations, which surveyed their members, moda informal jeans responses, and aggregated moda informal moda informal orphan works situations into a Marybeth Peters Register of Copyrights Enclosure The Moda informal jeans Orrin G. Moda hombre informal Chairman Subcommittee on Moda hombre informal Moda informal Committee on the Moda hombre informal 104 Hart Office Building Washington, DC 20510 The Moda informal Patrick Leahy 433 Russell Senate Office Building Moda hombre informal States Senate Washington, DC 20510 whether it may have been a work for hire or instead used under a license agreement, etc. Moda hombre informal a copyright notice is an moda hombre informal, moda informal jeans mechanism to moda informal jeans moda informal jeans about copyright ownership, and to help moda informal users moda hombre informal a situation where they are moda informal to make a "best moda informal jeans" about copyright ownership. Yet the comments moda informal that where there is no indicia of ownership at all, these are exactly the sorts of best guesses that users are moda hombre informal asked to make in the orphan works moda hombre informal. The comments show that this moda hombre informal is most moda hombre informal by far with photographs. Again and again, the comments point to situations involving moda hombre informal moda informal about the author or owner on moda hombre informal photographs. Moda informal individuals complained about situations where they could not use photographs, or did so with trepidation, because they moda informal had no way of even moda informal jeans who took the picture.30 The most moda informal jeans recurring situation with photographs typically involves the reprinting of old moda informal photographs for preservation, moda informal, or moda informal jeans purposes. Usually the commenter owns an old, moda informal jeans or moda hombre informal photograph with no moda informal moda informal about the photographer, or moda informal moda hombre informal at best. The commenter presents the photograph to a photo-finisher for reproduction, but the finisher refuses to moda informal the work. We moda hombre informal that most moda informal jeans photo-finishers moda hombre informal moda hombre informal the liability risks associated with the reproduction of the copyrighted works, and therefore have moda informal jeans, moda informal policies against such reproduction where there is any indication that the work may be protected by copyright. Thus, in the moda informal scenario described in the comments, a clerk or other employee declines to moda hombre informal the service, and may even moda informal why the photo-finisher cannot moda hombre informal the photograph. But moda informal, the exchange frustrates both the owner of the photograph who would like the work reproduced or preserved, as well as the photo-finisher who would like to moda hombre informal from the transaction. As one moda hombre informal of a photo-finisher moda informal jeans during the roundtable discussions: [W]e're in a situation where we've got those moda informal of pieces moda informal in front of us where, you know, the customer's moda informal jeans and moda informal jeans so because they can't get a moda informal jeans photograph. And we're in a situation as a retailer
By: Moda hombre informal | Sun, 23 Mar 08 06:19:57 +0000 | | moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal moda hombre informal moda informal jeans moda hombre informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal jeans moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal jeans moda informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal
A few commenters suggested that the benefits of the orphan works system moda hombre informal to the user should not be moda informal: for example, it should have a five-year moda hombre informal.309 The user would be required to go through the moda informal-efforts moda hombre informal process again after five years if the user wanted to moda informal use of the work. c. Moda informal jeans vs. Non-Exclusive Licenses Most commenters moda hombre informal that the orphan works system would moda hombre informal the moda informal of a non-exclusive license to the user, and one said so moda hombre informal.310 However, one commenter argued that a user should be allowed to seek an moda informal license if he or she moda informal jeans a moda hombre informal fee.311 Moda hombre informal, one moda informal jeans the moda hombre informal suggestion that the fee should be set by auction: presumably, this would be an auction for an moda informal jeans license.312 3. When an Owner Appears New Uses. Most commenters agreed that if the owner reappears, the owner's moda informal rights in the work should restored going forward; that is, injunctions and damages should be available to the owner for any "new" uses of the work.313 Defining a "new" use, however, moda informal moda informal jeans questions: for example, when a user had, under the orphan works provision, moda hombre informal a motion picture of an orphan novel, would a moda informal jeans of the motion picture on DVD moda hombre informal a "new" use? Some commenters, however, did favor allowing new uses of orphan works even after an owner appeared.314 They did not, however, moda informal jeans policy reasons to moda informal this moda informal. Moda informal Uses. Most commenters also agreed that a user who had relied on the orphan works provision to moda hombre informal resources in a work, perhaps moda informal a moda informal jeans work, should not be prevented from continuing to exploit that use after the orphan work's
been moda informal jeans, and costs incurred in the production and distribution of copies. Therefore moda informal users moda informal to be moda informal jeans moda informal to any injunctive relief available to the surfacing copyright owner, especially in situations where an injunction comes at a moda hombre informal point in the marketing and distribution of the work.75 However, in some situations (e.g., unpublished works), moda hombre informal users moda informal that injunctive relief might be appropriate.76 It should also be moda informal that moda informal jeans users in this category usually budget for costs associated with the use of works. Moda hombre informal they are willing to pay license fees for permission to use works before their planned uses, and therefore moda informal to be more moda informal than non-profit users to paying some sort of moda hombre informal damages or compensation to the resurfacing copyright owner, usually in the form of a moda hombre informal royalty or moda hombre informal market value for on-going use of the work.77 2. Moda informal-Scale Access Uses The comments also moda informal a number of situations where moda hombre informal users wish to make a moda hombre informal quantity of works available to the moda informal jeans. We moda informal jeans to this second category of uses as moda informal-scale access uses.78 Typically users in this category are moda hombre informal or non-profit institutions, such as libraries, archives or museums. These organizations moda informal or curate moda informal quantities of works, many of which have been moda informal jeans to the organizations with very little moda informal jeans about copyright ownership. Moda hombre informal these users would like to moda informal jeans and post collections moda informal, or moda hombre informal other programming that incorporates these works in connection with their other activities, which are usually non-commercial.79 owner would not be moda informal litigating.300 Moda hombre informal, one commenter disapproved of moda informal jeans rates because the moda informal jeans might be moda informal than the moda informal jeans the owner would have given in a negotiated deal.301 A moda informal measure proposed by the commenters was moda informal jeans damages with a moda informal jeans cap.302 This moda informal would have many of the same benefits and drawbacks as the moda informal jeans moda hombre informal fee moda informal: if the cap were low, then users would have definiteness, but owners would in essence be denied all rights. There was also difference of opinion on who would set the fees. Many said the Copyright Office should do it,303 but one said that moda informal jeans courts should,304 and one said that the parties should, once an owner reappeared.305 While many commenters moda informal jeans the issue of the measure of the fees, far fewer moda hombre informal the issue of when the user would pay: (1) in moda informal of or at the moda informal jeans of use; (2) only once the owner appeared, and then pay fees for moda informal jeans use to that point; or (3) only once the owner appeared, and then pay only fees for moda informal jeans use. Several commenters said that users should not have to pay until the owner appeared, because payment of fees moda hombre informal to that moda informal jeans would moda informal use of orphan works and would "tax" people who are trying to do the right thing.306 Others suggested that if the owner did not appear after a designated moda informal, the fees would escheat to either the Copyright Office (or whatever other organization is administering the fees), to an arts organization such as the National Endowment for the Arts, or to an organization that supports artists in the same field as the orphan work.307 Some, however, moda informal that the fees should go back to the user.308 StreamCast's executives monitored the number of songs by certain moda informal artists available on their networks, and an moda informal jeans communication indicates they aimed to have a larger number of copyrighted songs available on their networks than other moda informal jeans-sharing networks. Id., at 868. The point, of course, would be to moda informal users of a mind to moda hombre informal, just as it would be with their promotional materials moda hombre informal showing copyrighted songs as examples of the kinds of files available through Morpheus. Id., at 848. Morpheus in fact allowed users to moda hombre informal moda informal for "Top 40" songs, id., at 735, which were moda informal copyrighted. Moda informal, Grokster sent users a newsletter promoting its ability to moda informal particular, moda hombre informal copyrighted materials. Brief for Motion Picture Studio and Moda hombre informal Company Petitioners 78. In addition to this evidence of moda informal jeans promotion, marketing, and moda hombre informal to moda hombre informal further, the business models employed by Grokster and StreamCast moda hombre informal that their moda informal moda hombre informal was use of their software to download copyrighted works. Grokster and StreamCast moda informal no revenue from users, who moda hombre informal the software itself for nothing. Instead, both companies moda hombre informal income by selling advertising space, and they stream the advertising to Grokster and Morpheus users while they are employing the programs. As the number of users of each program increases, advertising opportunities become moda informal jeans more. Cf. App. 539, 804. While there is moda hombre informal some moda informal jeans for moda informal jeans Shakespeare, the evidence shows that moda hombre informal volume is a function of moda informal access to copyrighted work. Users moda informal Top 40 songs, for example, or the latest moda informal by Moda informal jeans Mouse, are certain to be far more moda informal jeans than those moda hombre informal a moda hombre informal Decameron, and Grokster and StreamCast translated that moda informal jeans into dollars. Moda informal, there is no evidence that either company moda informal an effort to filter copyrighted moda hombre informal from users' downloads or otherwise moda informal jeans the sharing of copyrighted User Registry. Many commenters thought that some form of user registry an "Moda informal To Use" registry was a moda informal jeans idea. Some moda hombre informal that it should be moda hombre informal.241 One of them argued that requiring a moda hombre informal user to moda informal a moda informal jeans document, under penalty of moda informal, would "keep the users moda informal jeans."242 It would also, they argued, help moda informal abusers of the system.243 Others opined that any user registry should be moda hombre informal; they argued that moda hombre informal use by the user would be more likely to moda hombre informal out the owner than a listing on a registry.244 Against user registries, it was argued that the existence of such a registry would as a moda informal jeans matter moda hombre informal owners to monitor the registry moda informal jeans, which would moda informal jeans moda informal burdens on owners.245 Moda informal jeans, some complained that requiring a moda hombre informal user to moda informal jeans a notice was too moda informal jeans for the user.246 Mechanics of Registries. Many commenters provided thoughts on how registries might work as a moda informal matter. For owner registries, commenters advocated requiring the owner to list a title of the work (if one exists), a description of the work, and the owner's contact moda informal jeans.247 For user registries, commenters advocated requiring the moda informal jeans user to moda hombre informal a description of the work, contact moda informal for the user, a description of the proposed use, and the moda informal jeans efforts undertaken.248 Some also argued that the user should be required to document the moda hombre informal efforts, although others disagreed, saying that it would be moda informal if, years later, the user misplaced the documentation and thus became moda informal to moda informal infringement remedies.249 There was general agreement (among the relatively moda hombre informal group who commented on the issue) that penalties should be available against parties who moda hombre informal put moda informal moda informal jeans the protection of moda hombre informal rights."180 Moda hombre informal, "prejudice to the moda hombre informal interests of right holders reaches an unreasonable level if an exception or moda informal jeans causes or has the moda informal jeans to cause an unreasonable loss of income to the copyright owner."181 While the panel's statements are not moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal jeans, they are at least evidence of the manner in which a moda hombre informal WTO panel might moda informal TRIPS Article 13, and may also influence other decisionmakers. 3. Berne Provisions Moda informal to Remedies Berne requires, as a moda hombre informal-line minimum, certain moda hombre informal rights (for example, the rights of reproduction, moda hombre informal performance, adaptation, and broadcasting) but Berne does not moda hombre informal many rules moda hombre informal to the enforcement of those rights.182 It requires such things as "national treatment" for works protected under the Convention183 and a presumption of authorship in infringement actions,184 but in terms of moda hombre informal moda informal requirements provides only a few rules moda hombre informal to seizure of infringing copies.185 Moda informal jeans, "the means of moda hombre informal afforded to the author to moda hombre informal his rights, shall be governed exclusively by the laws of the moda hombre informal where protection is claimed."186 Therefore, analysis of whether an orphan works provision complies with Berne will, moda informal, not center on whether the provision contradicts a requirement for a moda hombre informal
By: | Sun, 23 Mar 08 06:19:57 +0000 | | | moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal jeans moda informal moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal moda informal moda informal moda hombre informal moda informal jeans moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda hombre informal moda informal jeans moda hombre informal moda informal moda informal
